Comparison
Virtual Assistant vs AI Assistant Pricing: What a Month of Help Costs (2026)
10 hours of a human virtual assistant: $390 a month. An AI assistant plan: $20. That’s about 20 times cheaper. But none of the AI pricing pages we read sell you an hour, so what is that $20 actually buying?
Watch the video version above, or read the full breakdown below. Every number links to the page it came from.
The Test Owner (a model, not a measurement)
Here’s the owner. One person running a small business, with about 10 hours a month of admin work they’d like off their plate. Inbox, scheduling, research, follow-ups.
For each company, we price one plan, and we name it below. Prices are list prices in dollars. This is a model, not a person we watched.
The Human Option: Billed by the Hour
Time etc sells a human assistant by the hour. 10 hours is $390 a month. The page does the math for you: $39 an hour. 20 hours is $760, 40 hours is $1,480, sixty hours is $2,160. The hourly rate drops $1 per step.
The plan card says you get a dedicated U.S. assistant, unused hours roll over, and you can switch plans or cancel any time.
One line on that page matters for this comparison. In their words, you only pay for work your Time etc assistant actually completes. The unit is finished human hours. We found only monthly prices, so we don’t quote a yearly one.
Sources: [1] timeetc.com · [2] timeetc.com · [3] timeetc.com · [4] timeetc.com · [5] timeetc.com
The AI Option, Part One: Billed by Usage
Claude Pro is $20 a month billed monthly, or $17 a month on the annual discount, which is $200 billed up front. Max starts from $100 a month and offers five times or 20 times more usage than Pro. The page text we pulled doesn’t print a separate twenty-times price, so we only quote from $100.
Now the unit. Pro lists hand off and schedule tasks. But the page measures what you get as usage. Pro gives at least five times more usage per five-hour session than Free, and usage limits apply. That’s a window of time, not hours of work done for you. So $20 buys access with a ceiling, not 10 hours.
Sources: [6] claude.com · [7] claude.com · [8] claude.com · [9] claude.com · [10] claude.com
The AI Option, Part Two: Billed by Credits
Lindy sells an AI assistant by credits. On the Team plan, 5,000 credits a month cost $49.99, and every active user in your workspace is billed. One catch: the page didn’t always open on the same tier. On some loads, Team started at $29.99 for 3,000 credits. We price the five-thousand tier, because it showed up on every load. Run out and you can top up at $10 per thousand credits.
Lindy’s page gives a range per job. Everyday asks, two to 250 credits. Deep work, like researching a competitor and writing the report, 250 to a thousand. Big builds, a thousand to 2,500.
So here’s our arithmetic. If every job you handed over were deep work, 5,000 credits would cover somewhere between five and 20 of those jobs a month. That’s a calculation from their ranges, not a count we ran.
Three more lines from the page. Monthly credits don’t roll over. When you run out, Lindy pauses credit-using actions until the next cycle, so no surprise bill. And anything with outside impact, such as sending an email, waits for your approval. Keep that last one in mind. Approving is still your time.
Sources: [11] lindy.ai · [12] lindy.ai · [13] lindy.ai · [14] lindy.ai
The Monthly Bill
Here’s the month, side by side. Claude Pro, $20. Lindy Team, $49.99 for one user. Claude Max, from $100. Time etc, $390 for 10 hours.
On price alone, the human plan is about 20 times Claude Pro and about eight times Lindy. But look at the bottom row. Usage, credits, usage, hours. Those are four bills in three different units.
Over a year on monthly billing, that’s $4,680 at Time etc, $1,200 at Claude Max, $599.88 at Lindy, and $240 at Claude Pro, or 200 up front on the annual discount.
Sources: [1] timeetc.com · [6] claude.com · [8] claude.com · [11] lindy.ai
What We Did Not Measure
What we did not measure: how many hours of human work any AI plan actually replaces, the quality or error rate of the work, your own time spent reviewing and approving, and what happens past any usage limit. Those are the numbers that decide the real cost, and no pricing page prints them.
How to Choose
So here’s the short version. First, write down the unit each plan sells: hours, usage, or credits. Second, price your real month in that unit, not the headline number. Third, count your own review time as part of the bill, because an AI plan that needs your approval on every email is not free hours.
Sources and Evidence
Each line below is quoted or paraphrased from the vendor’s or author’s own page, retrieved on the date shown.
- Time etc Ten hours: $390 per month; that’s $39 per hour. — timeetc.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Time etc larger plans: Twenty hours $760 ($38 per hour); Forty hours $1480 ($37 per hour); Sixty hours $2160 ($36 per hour). — timeetc.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Time etc plan card: Dedicated U.S. assistant; Unused hours rollover; Switch plans or cancel any time. — timeetc.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Time etc: you only pay for work your Time etc assistant actually completes. — timeetc.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Our reading: Time etc’s page text shows monthly prices only; no yearly price appears, so we do not quote one. — timeetc.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Claude Pro: $20 if billed monthly; $17 per month with annual subscription discount ($200 billed up front). — claude.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Claude Pro lists Hand off and schedule tasks. — claude.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Claude Max: From $100 per month; choose 5x or 20x more usage than Pro. — claude.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Our reading: The Max 20x monthly price is not printed in the page text we pulled; we quote only From $100. — claude.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Our reading: Claude’s page measures plans as usage per 5-hour session (Pro: at least 5x more usage per 5-hour session than Free) and says Usage limits apply. Our reading: the unit is usage within a time window, not hours of work. — claude.com (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Lindy Team: the 5,000-credit tier is $49.99 per month; every active user in your workspace is billed; top up anytime at $10 per 1,000 credits. — lindy.ai (published 2026-10-18 · retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Lindy credit ranges: Everyday Asks 2-250 credits; Deep work 250-1,000 credits (e.g. research a competitor and write the report); Big Builds 1,000-2,500 credits. — lindy.ai (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Lindy: monthly credits don’t roll over; when credits run out Lindy pauses credit-using actions until reset; anything with outside impact waits for approval, such as sending an email. — lindy.ai (retrieved 2026-10-15)
- Lindy’s pricing page did not always open on the same Team tier: on some loads Team started at $29.99 for 3,000 credits, on others at $49.99 for 5,000 credits. The 5,000-credit tier at $49.99 appeared on every load. — lindy.ai (retrieval date not recorded)